PRODUCT
LIABILITY INSURANCE — A MUST!
By Larry Heller, Palomar
Insurance Group
“Two kids riding a go-kart
on a highway were hit from behind by a car. The kart rolled and the gas
tank exploded. Both were seriously injured…”
“A little girl riding
a go-kart got her long hair caught in the drive chain, resulting in serious,
permanent injury…”
If you manufactured one
of these karts, sold it, or even made a component part, there is a high
probability you will be involved in a lengthy lawsuit. Your legal expenses
alone could be substantial and claims exceeding $1 million have occurred.
Your chances of winning a lawsuit against a seriously injured child are
slim. In most states, all parties can be held jointly and severally liable,
which could require you to pay the entire judgment, even if you did very
little wrong. Thank heaven accidents like those above don’t happen everyday.
However, when karting accidents do happen, they tend to be severe.
Product Liability Insurance
protects manufacturers, distributors and dealers from losses like these.
However, Product Liability Insurance is not all you need either. Comprehensive
General Liability Insurance including Product Liability should be considered
minimum protection.
Insurance is expensive
and there is no physical product to examine to determine if you are getting
good value for your money. For example, when you buy tires for a kart,
you examine them to make certain the quality fits your needs, make sure
the manufacturer will stand behind them, then seek the lowest price available.
You should do the same with insurance. But how?
Insurance is very technical
and this writer cannot tell you everything there is to know in adequate
detail in this short article. You should know that there are two types
of Product Liability Insurance:
1) Claims-made
2) Occurrence
The companies that provide
this insurance are “non-admitted” or “surplus lines” carriers. They are
largely unregulated, their policies are not standard (some are very restrictive),
their financial condition is a primary consideration and premiums may vary
widely.
If this sounds confusing,
it is! Buying insurance based on price alone can be a mistake that may
cost you your business. The following are some of the major areas you should
discuss with your agent before you buy insurance.
Financial Ability—
Nothing is worse than
paying a large premium, then discovering your insurance company is bankrupt
when you need it the most. This happens. How can you protect yourself?
The most widely used method is to ask your agent to tell you the ‘Best
Rating’ of a selected carrier. Companies rated less than “A” or not rated
at all may be cause for concern.
Occurrence VS Claims-made—
The difference between
the two basic forms of Product Liability Insurance is in the time period
of coverage. Neither covers accidents that happen before their effective
date. You are covered under an Occurrence policy if the accident happened
during the policy period. Claims-made requires that the accident occur
and be reported during the policy period.
It takes months, sometimes
years for manufacturers to be notified of an accident. This will sound
confusing, but it’s fact: Claims-made coverage handles late-reported claims
under future policies by establishment of a retroactive date, which is
the date you first bought the Claims-made policy. Accidents that happened
after the retroactive date are covered if reported during the current policy
period. Occurrence coverage is preferred, even if the initial premium is
greater.
Deductibles and Self-Insured
Retention—
Kart manufacturers Product
Liability policies commonly contain one of these. Both are ways to reduce
your premium. Both are similar in that you pay for part of the claim, usually
including legal expenses up to the amount selected. With a deductible,
the insurance company pays the claim and bills you. With a Self-Insured
Retention (SIR), you adjust the claim up to the level selected. Large SIRs
require you to contract with a service to handle claims, and the insurance
company may require a Letter of Credit.
Contractual Liability
Coverage—
Purchase orders and other
contracts may at times include agreements that you will assume someone
else’s liability. If a product claim occurs, your policy may cover you
liability, but not cover the liability you agree to assume. Contractual
Liability coverage is designed to fill that void. It is inexpensive and
is included in most Broadening Endorsements.
Vendor’s Liability/Additional
Insureds—
Manufacturers can agree
to insure their distributors for much of their Product Liability and name
them as additional insureds under a policy. However, doing so results in
splitting liability limits with the distributor. Adding the manufacturer
of a component part as an additional insured has the same effect. Insurance
companies usually charge an additional 15-20% to do this.
Punitive Damages—
In many states, juries
can award these special payments as punishment. Some insurance companies
specifically exclude these damages. While they don’t happen often and cannot
be insured in some states, a policy with an exclusion is preferable.
Broadening Endorsement—
This is a package of
commonly requested coverages, including Contractual Liability. Many insurance
companies automatically include it, others charge extra. It is inexpensive
and the coverage is important.
Limits—
Product Liability limits
of $1 million per claim, $2 million annual aggregate are required, and
represent the minimum you should consider. The aggregate is the maximum
protection for more than one claim in one year. The amount sounds like
a lot, but claims have exceeded even the minimum limit. Higher limits are
available and should be considered. You can increase the policy limit but
a better option may be to purchase an Umbrella Liability Policy.
Loss Adjustment Expense—
Attorney’s fees for your
defense, the cost of the investigation, etc. are normally included in your
policy in addition to the policy limit. In serious cases, these expenses
may rage from $50,000 to $200,000 or more. Some companies include these
expenses within your policy limit. Your $1 million limit could be reduced
to $800,000 or less available to pay the judgment. Obviously, a policy
where these expenses are included outside your policy limit is preferred.
Deposit Premium—
This is an upfront charge
based on the estimated sales you list in the insurance application. Your
premium will be adjusted after the policy expires t reflect your annual
sales during the year. Understanding your sales will result I having to
pay an additional premium plus the renewal policy premium at the same time.
Conclusion—
Remember, when you compare
insurance policy prices, the lowest price may not be the best deal. Policies
are not all the same and the financial condition of the insurance company
is critical. Your policy doesn’t make good wallpaper, and it is not interesting
to read. Make certain it is worth what you are paying for it. Your insurance
agent should thoroughly explain each of these areas and the differences
between policies to help you make valid comparisons.
Note: Additional Product
Liability Insurance information is available from Palomar Insurance Group,
PO Drawer 11128, Montgomery, Alabama 36111. Phone 800-489-0105.
END
View
Past "Fun Times" Articles |